Turns out, the Crazy Man was right! Treasure Island isn’t a myth. It’s real, it’s weird, and it’s packed with some of the most exclusive fish in Fisch. More specifically, there are just over a dozen unique species, including the Gemstone Whale Shark, Ruby Lionfish, Goldfin Octopus, and Queen Angelfish.
And guess what? They’re all for the taking! Here’s how to find Treasure Island in Fisch and complete its entire Bestiary.
How To Find Treasure Island In Fisch
To find Treasure Island in Fisch, go to the Isle of New Beginnings in the Second Sea and wait for Tornado weather. When it hits, a glowing orange Treasure Whale will spawn at the southern tip. Before boarding it, talk to the Crazy Man at GPS X: -470, Y: 83, Z: 378 to start the quest.
Hit “Travel” when prompted, and you’ll be taken to Whale Interior. After about 90 seconds, you’ll be auto-teleported to Treasure Island in Fisch (at GPS X: -1787, Y: 134, Z: -11973). That’s where you’ll be able to catch and appraise exclusive fish species and score the shiny Treasure Rod.

How To Complete Treasure Island Bestiary In Fisch
To complete the Treasure Island Bestiary, you’ll need to catch the following 12 fish species in Fisch (excluding the Secret rarity Goldfin Octopus). To maximize your odds, I suggest using the preferred baits indicated in the table below. None of these fish has any preference for specific conditions of weather, season, or time.
Fish | Rarity | Preferred Bait |
---|---|---|
Coin Triggerfish | Common | Bagel |
Emerald Angelfish | Common | Insect |
Crowned Royal Gramma | Common | Worm |
Bluegem Angelfish | Common | Shrimp |
Gemscale Mandarinfish | Uncommon | Mist Worm |
Goldband Butterflyfish | Uncommon | Gale Grub |
Golden Dorado | Unsual | Lushrooms |
Hidden Filefish | Unusual | Lagoon Leach |
Queen Angelfish | Rare | Minnow |
Net Wolffish | Rare | Squid |
Ruby Lionfish | Legendary | Crystal Bananas |
Gemstone Whale Shark | Mythical | Saphhire Krill |
Goldfin Octopus | Exotic | Shrimp Bait |

Pro Tip: You can get the Golden Shrimp Bait (1,500E$) and Whale Bait (800E$) from the vendor in Whale Interior.
That’s how to complete the Treasure Island bestiary in Fisch. Hungry for more? Check out even more guides in our Adopt Me!, Bubble Gum Simulator INFINITY, Pet Simulator 99, Beaks, or Blue Lock Rivals sections.